If you gathered all my closest (or at least friendliest) friends in a room, I’m pretty sure most of them would say they like who I am. I’m not sure which good qualities they’d mention, though — it likely would change from person to person, and might even depend on when they met me.
But if you asked about my flaws — the things about me that earn eye rolls at the low end, and fury at the top end — I’m pretty sure I know what those are.
I spend a lot of time thinking about what it means to be a friend, actually, and where the bonds come from that draw us to one another, and keep us there.
When I was younger, friendship was more about proximity and frequency than anything else. If we were always together, we were friends, whether we drove one another nuts or not. I moved once after kindergarten, and once in the middle of the fifth grade — which meant I learned to be an accepting, tolerant friend so I would actually have friends. Only true queen bees can come out of nowhere and demand deference, and I was clearly a pollen forager, not the master of my hive. Some of the friendships I built then were amazing, but some of them felt like an early draft of the Mean Girls script. But who was I to complain?
When I was a little older, friendship seemed to evolve from shared experiences. I worked three months every summer at a camp on an island, and built relationships there that continue to this day, though I don’t see most of those friends often anymore. We created some amazing memories, and as a result, the people I worked with became my favorite people. I think my high school friendships suffered as a result, on top of the reality that I’d moved to a medium-town-with-a-small-town-mentality long after people had chosen their allegiances, and didn’t quite fit in.
I look back at the strange combination of insanely confident and oddly insecure I was at that point, and both sides make sense, though I felt like a split personality. On one hand, I could stand up on a stage and do anything without blinking, or lead 300 people in ridiculous activities without thinking twice. On the other hand, I was starting to wonder if I would always be “the friend” to guys around me, not “the girlfriend” — a reality I tied unquestioningly to my appearance — and becoming more shy and nervous as a result. With everyone, not just potential dates.
To be sure, my weight played a role in both aspects of my personality: I wanted to be loved in spite of my hips, so I would be the most intensely silly, engaged, fierce, giving, present version of myself. As a skinny, athletic kid, I hadn’t had anything to compensate for, but sure I felt like I did now. And I still feel like that, even as a 38-year old married woman who knows the weight hangs on because of radically early menopause and an autoimmune disorder. Back then, however, there was no “excuse”: there was something wrong with me, and I’d have to get people to look past it.
That worked for friends, but when it came to love? I was a bit of a mess. I didn’t think there was anything I could do to compensate there, so I became a serial crusher and “best girl friend” and pseudo-girlfriend. The amount of passive rejection and heartbreak that defined those years is cringeworthy to me now — I shouldn’t even have cared about half of them, from the ones who told me I had a “pretty face”, but… to the ones who told me I was “wife material”, while chatting up my prettier friends on the side.
After that phase in life, my friendships seemed to arise from shared personality traits and lifestyle, especially after I finally settled in one place for a while. My close girlfriends were hilarious, boisterous, bright, caring… and more often than not, as single as I was. Almost the entire set of friends I’d made in my late teens and twenties were married, so they were less available to me, or more interested in friendships with people at a similar phase in life. Or so I thought — and I was undoubtedly wrong. More than anything, I was defending myself against feeling like a third wheel, which had everything to do with how I saw myself, and very little to do with how they made me feel.
Yes, some married folks turn into pod people when rings are exchanged — but for the most part, I think the change was in me. I loved being Auntie Meg to their kids when I would see them, and I loved seeing so many of my friends so happy… but my single girlfriends got the bulk of my time because they didn’t remind me what was “missing.”
The start of my blog in 2004 brought some new people into my life — in addition to (eventually) a husband for my best friend, Catherine. Eric came to visit us in Vancouver from San Diego after a year of emails and phone calls between the three of us, and over the next couple of years (and more trips back and forth), he and she fell in love. I was a little jealous, to be sure — but now I know that the success of that connection made me willing to take the leap to meet Gradon a few years later.
A leap that turned out well, really — and that’s a radical understatement. Followed by another leap to a new city, where I was once again in the position of making new friendships, and figuring out what they’d be based on, and what I had to offer — questions I considered both subconsciously and consciously, because I’ve developed a capacity for overthinking that could power a city block if harnessed.
Since I’ve been here — two years now — I’ve built some friendships, and seen friendships I’d intended to work on fall by the wayside. And those are on me, for the most part, because I’m good at isolating myself instead of stretching my little turtle legs and arms out of my shell.
I wonder if people are just being nice to me because they like my husband (he is VERY likeable.)
I wonder if I fit in, or if I’m too conservative or not conservative enough or too loud or not loud enough or too emotional or not emotional enough or yadda yadda yadda.
I wonder if my values and loves don’t make any sense to them.
I wonder if I’m at a stage of life that they can’t identify with at all.
I wonder if they’re judging how I look because they don’t know my history… or do know, and don’t care.
I wonder if they’d rather be hanging out with someone funnier / cooler / more like them / with a shared history / etc.
You combine all that obnoxious wondering with long days that sap my desire to make plans — commuting or working from 7:45 to 7:30 every day, before eating and sleeping or existing with my husband — and I haven’t really been a great friend to anyone as of late. Not my friends back in Vancouver, not my friends here. I feel like I should be better at keeping in touch, because of all the moving and uprooting I’ve done. I’ve had practice!
So what’s going on?
Here’s what I think: same things as always.
And where I used to just feel these things, now I feel them… and I’m annoyed by them.
YOU ARE 38 YEARS OLD! Why can’t you get over it? Why do you care so much? Why are you isolating yourself from new relationships AND the old ones that you should be perfectly secure in? Why don’t you own the connections you make instead of questioning them? Why do you care if those people have things you don’t? Why do you care if you have things they don’t? Why don’t you own your fat ass and tell anyone who can’t handle it to go screw? Why don’t you think less and do more?
Maybe the relationships I’ll build in the next phase of my life won’t be based on proximity or shared experiences or similar qualities or life situations, but rather anyone who can wait out the weird.
But if I’m honest with myself, that was likely the case all along.